Skip to content

Investigating Force, Mass and Acceleration: The Trolley Practical Explained

A clear guide to the trolley practical for F = ma: the equipment, a step-by-step method, how light gates give the acceleration, what the graphs of a against F and a against 1/m show, and how to reduce errors.

Published · 8 min read

On this page

In this practical, a falling mass on a string pulls a trolley along a runway, and you measure the trolley's acceleration. There are two parts. In the first, you change the force but keep the mass the same. In the second, you change the mass but keep the force the same.

The results show two patterns. When the mass is fixed, the acceleration is directly proportional to the force: double the force, and the acceleration doubles. When the force is fixed, the acceleration is inversely proportional to the mass: double the mass, and the acceleration halves. Put together, these patterns give Newton's second law, F=maF = ma.

What equipment do you need?

  • a trolley with low-friction wheels
  • a long, smooth runway or bench
  • a pulley clamped to the end of the bench
  • string, and a mass hanger with slotted masses (for example, 50 g each)
  • two light gates connected to a data logger, and a card fixed on top of the trolley
  • a metre rule and a balance
  • a box of padding under the pulley to catch the falling masses

No light gates? A ticker timer and paper tape will work. Most ticker timers print 50 dots per second, so every 5 dot-spaces is 0.1 s. A stopwatch also works, but less reliably.

How does the hanging mass make the trolley accelerate?

The string runs from the trolley, over the pulley and down to the mass hanger. When you let go, the weight of the hanging masses pulls the trolley along. Trolley and hanger move together, with the same acceleration.

So the accelerating force is the weight of everything hanging on the string, W=mgW = mg. If the hanger and its masses total 100 g, the force is 0.100 × 9.8 = 0.98 N.

The mass being accelerated is the whole system: the trolley, the hanger and every slotted mass, wherever it sits. This idea is the key to the first part of the practical.

Why move masses from the trolley to the hanger?

In part 1, you want to change the force but keep the mass constant. If you just added extra masses to the hanger, you would increase the force and the total mass at the same time. That would not be a fair test.

So start with most of the slotted masses on the trolley. To increase the force, lift one mass off the trolley and put it on the hanger. The force goes up, but the total mass of the system does not change at all.

Worked example 1: predicting the acceleration

A trolley has a mass of 0.75 kg. The hanger and slotted masses have a total mass of 0.25 kg. At first, 0.10 kg hangs on the string and the rest sits on the trolley. Find the accelerating force and the acceleration. Ignore friction and take g = 9.8 N/kg.

Given: total mass m = 0.75 + 0.25 = 1.00 kg, hanging mass = 0.10 kg

Force: F=0.10×9.8=0.98 NF = 0.10 \times 9.8 = 0.98\ \text{N}

Equation: a=Fma = \dfrac{F}{m}, using the total mass

Substitution: a=0.981.00a = \dfrac{0.98}{1.00}

Answer: a=0.98 m/s2a = 0.98\ \text{m/s}^2

Now move another 0.10 kg to the hanger. The force doubles to 1.96 N, the total mass is still 1.00 kg, and the acceleration doubles to 1.96 m/s². With g = 10 N/kg, as in some courses, you would get 1.0 and 2.0 m/s².

What do the light gates measure?

A light gate sends a beam of light across a gap to a sensor. As the trolley passes, the card on top blocks the beam. The data logger records how long the beam stays blocked. The speed at that gate is:

speed=length of cardtime the beam is blocked\text{speed} = \frac{\text{length of card}}{\text{time the beam is blocked}}

With two gates, you get a starting speed u at the first gate and a final speed v at the second. The logger also times how long the trolley takes to get from one gate to the other. Then:

a=v−uta = \frac{v - u}{t}

Many data loggers do this sum for you.

Worked example 2: acceleration from light gate readings

A card 5.0 cm long is fixed to a trolley. It blocks the first light gate for 0.125 s and the second for 0.040 s. The trolley takes 0.85 s to travel between the gates. Find the acceleration.

Given: card length = 5.0 cm = 0.050 m, times = 0.125 s and 0.040 s, t = 0.85 s

Speed at gate 1: u=0.0500.125=0.40 m/su = \dfrac{0.050}{0.125} = 0.40\ \text{m/s}

Speed at gate 2: v=0.0500.040=1.25 m/sv = \dfrac{0.050}{0.040} = 1.25\ \text{m/s}

Equation: a=v−uta = \dfrac{v - u}{t}

Substitution: a=1.25−0.400.85a = \dfrac{1.25 - 0.40}{0.85}

Answer: a=1.0 m/s2a = 1.0\ \text{m/s}^2 (2 significant figures)

Here u is the speed at the first gate and v is the speed at the second. If your course writes these as viv_i and vfv_f, the working is exactly the same.

If you measure the distance between the gates instead of the time, use v2=u2+2asv^2 = u^2 + 2as. Here the gates would be about 0.70 m apart, which gives the same answer. With a ticker tape, you can plot a velocity–time graph and take its gradient. The motion graphs simulation shows why the gradient is the acceleration.

What is the method?

Part 1: changing the force, with the total mass fixed

  1. Set up the runway with the pulley at one end. Place the two light gates a fixed distance apart along the runway.
  2. Load all but one of the slotted masses onto the trolley. Put the last one on the hanger.
  3. Hold the trolley still at a marked start line, then let go without pushing.
  4. Record the acceleration from the data logger.
  5. Move one mass from the trolley to the hanger and repeat. Carry on until all the masses are hanging.
  6. Do each run three times and calculate a mean acceleration.

Part 2: changing the mass, with the force fixed

  1. Keep the same masses on the hanger for every run, so the force does not change.
  2. Add extra mass to the trolley, one step at a time. Stacking a second trolley on top also works.
  3. Record the acceleration three times for each mass and find the mean.
  4. Write down the total mass of the system each time, including the hanger.

What graphs should you get?

Acceleration against force. Plot acceleration up the side and force along the bottom. You should get a straight line. If friction is tiny, the line passes through the origin, which shows that a is directly proportional to F. The gradient equals 1 ÷ total mass.

Friction shifts the line. Part of the pulling force is used up just overcoming friction, so a small force gives no acceleration at all. The line is still straight, but it cuts the force axis at a positive value, roughly equal to the friction force, instead of passing through the origin.

Acceleration against mass. This gives a curve that drops steeply at first, then levels out. It is hard to prove inverse proportion from a curve by eye. So plot acceleration against 1/mass instead. A straight line through the origin shows that a is inversely proportional to m.

Worked example 3: reading the graph of a against F

A student's line of best fit passes through (0.15 N, 0 m/s²) and (1.35 N, 1.50 m/s²). Find the total mass of the system and estimate the friction force.

Given: two points on the line, (0.15, 0) and (1.35, 1.50)

Gradient: 1.50−01.35−0.15=1.501.20=1.25\dfrac{1.50 - 0}{1.35 - 0.15} = \dfrac{1.50}{1.20} = 1.25

Equation: gradient = 1m\dfrac{1}{m}, so m=1gradientm = \dfrac{1}{\text{gradient}}

Substitution: m=11.25m = \dfrac{1}{1.25}

Answer: m = 0.80 kg. The line meets the force axis at 0.15 N, so friction is about 0.15 N.

You can gather a full set of results in a few minutes with the force, mass and acceleration simulation. Record a set of runs with friction off, press Clear table, then record a second set with friction on and compare the two lines.

What are the variables?

PartIndependent variableDependent variableControl variables
1Force (weight of the hanging masses)AccelerationTotal mass, runway, card, start line, gate positions
2Total mass of the systemAccelerationHanging mass, runway, card, start line, gate positions

How can you reduce errors and improve the results?

  • Friction. Raise the end of the runway away from the pulley very slightly, until the trolley, given a gentle push with no string attached, rolls at a constant speed. Both light gates should show the same speed. A small part of the trolley's weight now acts down the slope and cancels friction. This is a friction-compensated runway.
  • Timing. Light gates remove human reaction time, the biggest source of error with a stopwatch.
  • Random errors. Repeat each run, leave out any anomalous results, and calculate a mean.
  • The string. Keep it parallel to the runway, so the whole pull acts along the track.
  • The card. Measure its length carefully, because every speed depends on it.

Common mistakes

  • Using only the trolley's mass. The hanging masses accelerate too, so include them.
  • Adding masses to the hanger without taking them off the trolley. This changes the force and the mass at once.
  • Using the hanging mass as the force. The force is its weight, mg, in newtons.
  • Forgetting to convert units. 50 g is 0.050 kg, and 5.0 cm is 0.050 m.
  • Forcing the line through the origin. If friction shifts it, draw the best straight line through your points.
  • Plotting a against m and stopping there. Plot a against 1/m to show inverse proportion.

Key points

  • With the mass fixed, acceleration is directly proportional to the resultant force.
  • With the force fixed, acceleration is inversely proportional to the mass.
  • The accelerating force is the weight of the hanging masses. The mass is the total of the trolley, hanger and slotted masses.
  • Moving masses from the trolley to the hanger changes the force while keeping the total mass constant.
  • Light gates give speed = card length ÷ time blocked, and then a=(v−u)/ta = (v - u)/t.
  • Friction makes the a–F line cut the force axis above zero. A friction-compensated runway fixes this.