Skip to content

Punjab Board Class 9 Physics · Turning effects of force

States of equilibrium and stability

Section 4.10Section 4.11Section 4.12

After a slight tilt, a body in stable equilibrium comes back (its G rises), one in unstable equilibrium moves further away (G falls) and one in neutral equilibrium stays in its new position (G keeps its height). A lower centre of gravity and a wider base make a body more stable.

Loading simulation…

Symbols match your course. Open the full centre of mass and stability simulation for more presets and teacher tools.

Three states of equilibrium

Draw a vertical line through the centre of gravity G of a body resting on a support. If that line passes through the support, the weight ww (down) and the normal reaction FNF_N (up) act along it, so there is no resultant force and no torque: both conditions of equilibrium are met. The state of equilibrium depends on what happens after a slight tilt.

Stable equilibrium: after a slight tilt, the body comes back to its original position.

Take a cone standing on its wide base and tilt it a little, so that it rests on one edge of the base. G rises. The upward reaction now acts at that edge, while the weight still acts down at G: two unlike parallel forces that are no longer in line. Because the vertical line through G is still inside the base, their torque pulls the cone back down onto its base. Any tilt that keeps this line inside the base ends the same way.

Unstable equilibrium: after a slight tilt, the body moves further away from its original position.

Balance the same cone on its sharp tip. The smallest tilt lowers G, and the line of action of the weight passes outside the tiny point of support. The torque of the weight turns the cone further over, and it falls.

Neutral equilibrium: after being moved, the body stays at rest in its new position.

Roll a cylinder lying on its side across a level table. G keeps the same height, and the weight and the reaction stay in one vertical line, so no torque acts. A football on flat ground and a cone lying on its curved side are neutral too.

StateAfter a slight tiltHeight of GExample
StableReturnsRisesCone on its base
UnstableMoves further awayFallsCone on its tip
NeutralStays in its new positionUnchangedCylinder on its side

Improving stability

A body is more stable when its centre of gravity is lower and its base is wider. Either change means it must tilt further before the vertical line through G leaves the base.

  • A low wooden peerhi is much harder to topple than a tall stool.
  • A van with heavy luggage on its roof has a raised G and can roll over on a sharp bend. Ships and double-decker buses keep their heavy parts low for the same reason.
  • A chair rocked back on its two rear legs is unstable: lean a little more and G passes behind them, so the weight and the reaction form a couple that tips it backwards.
  • Racing cars are built very low, with their wheels set out beyond the body, so G is low and the base is wide.
  • Balancing toys have heavy weights hanging below the pivot, so G is under the point of support. Any tilt raises G, and the toy swings back.

Worked numerical: an almirah tilted onto its edge

An 80 kg almirah is tilted forward onto its front edge and released. Take g=10 N kg−1g = 10\ \text{N kg}^{-1}.

(a) The vertical line through G is 0.20 m behind the front edge. Find the torque of the weight about that edge.

w=mg=80×10=800 Nw = mg = 80 \times 10 = 800\ \text{N} τ=w×ℓ=800 N×0.20 m=160 N m\tau = w \times \ell = 800\ \text{N} \times 0.20\ \text{m} = 160\ \text{N m}

The line through G is still over the base, so this torque turns the almirah back: it is stable.

(b) It is tipped further, until that line lies 0.05 m in front of the edge.

τ=800 N×0.05 m=40 N m\tau = 800\ \text{N} \times 0.05\ \text{m} = 40\ \text{N m}

This smaller torque acts the other way and topples the almirah.

Using the simulation

In the simulation above, choose Equilibrium under Experiment. The Stable set-up shows a cone on its base, with G 9.0 cm above the table.

  1. In the bar under the stage, press Tip. The cone leans 15° and G rises to 11.8 cm. Press Let go and it settles back.
  2. Press Tip four times, then Let go. The vertical line through G now falls outside the base, so the cone falls. Press Reset.
  3. Choose Unstable, press Tip, then Let go: the cone falls and G drops from 27.0 cm to 8.5 cm.
  4. Choose Neutral and press Tip. The cylinder rolls, but G stays at 11.0 cm.

Now open Tilt test. The Bookcase has its books on the Bottom shelf, and its critical angle (the tilt at which it starts to topple) is 26.57°. Press Tilt: the platform rises until the bookcase begins to tip at 26.57°. Choose Top shelf, which stands it up on a level platform. Now G sits 1.3 m up instead of 0.5 m, and the critical angle drops to 10.89°. The critical-angle formula is beyond your course; use it only to compare.

Common mistakes

  • Mixing up which way G moves. A slight tilt raises G in stable equilibrium, lowers it in unstable equilibrium and leaves its height unchanged in neutral equilibrium.
  • Saying a body topples as soon as it is tilted. It topples only when the vertical line through its centre of gravity passes outside its base.
  • Thinking a heavier body is always more stable. Stability depends on how low the centre of gravity is and how wide the base is.
  • Calling a cylinder standing upright on its flat end neutral. On its flat end it is stable; it is neutral only when lying on its curved side.
  • Placing the centre of gravity of a balancing toy above its pivot. Its heavy parts hang low, so G is below the point of support.
  • Forgetting that heavy luggage on a roof raises the centre of gravity of a vehicle and makes it easier to overturn.

Exam-style questions

Original questions written in the style of Punjab board exams. Try each one before you reveal the answer.

  1. 1.Bodies at rest can be in stable, unstable or neutral equilibrium.

    1. (a)Define stable, unstable and neutral equilibrium.

      3 marks
      Show the answer

      Answer: Stable: after a slight tilt the body returns to its original position. Unstable: after a slight tilt it moves further away from its original position. Neutral: after being displaced it stays at rest in its new position.

      Marking points

      • Stable: returns to its original position after a slight tilt
      • Unstable: moves further away from its original position after a slight tilt
      • Neutral: stays in its new position (height of G unchanged)
    2. (b)State the state of equilibrium of (i) a brick lying flat on the floor, (ii) a pencil balanced on its sharpened point, (iii) a football resting on level ground.

      3 marks
      Show the answer

      Answer: (i) Stable. (ii) Unstable. (iii) Neutral.

      Marking points

      • Brick: stable
      • Pencil on its point: unstable
      • Football: neutral
  2. 2.A solid cone stands on its base on a level table and is tilted slightly, then released.

    1. (a)Explain, in terms of its centre of gravity and the torque of its weight, why the cone returns to its original position.

      3 marks
      Show the answer

      Answer: Tilting raises the centre of gravity, but the vertical line through it still passes inside the base. The weight and the normal reaction at the edge now act along different lines as unlike parallel forces. They produce a torque that turns the cone back onto its base.

      Marking points

      • Centre of gravity rises but its vertical line stays within the base
      • Weight and reaction act along different lines (unlike parallel forces)
      • Their torque turns the cone back to its original position
    2. (b)Explain why the cone topples if it is tilted too far.

      2 marks
      Show the answer

      Answer: The vertical line through the centre of gravity passes outside the base. The torque of the weight then turns the cone further over instead of back.

      Marking points

      • Line of action of the weight falls outside the base
      • Torque of the weight turns it further over
  3. 3.A 60 kg filing cabinet is tilted onto one edge of its base and released. Take g = 10 N/kg.

    1. (a)Calculate the weight of the cabinet.

      1 mark
      Show the answer

      Answer: w = mg = 60 × 10 = 600 N.

      Marking points

      • 600 N
    2. (b)At release, the vertical line through its centre of gravity is 0.15 m from the edge it rests on, still over the base. Calculate the torque of the weight about that edge.

      2 marks
      Show the answer

      Answer: τ = w × ℓ = 600 N × 0.15 m = 90 N m.

      Marking points

      • τ = 600 × 0.15
      • 90 N m
    3. (c)State what this torque does to the cabinet.

      1 mark
      Show the answer

      Answer: It turns the cabinet back onto its base, so it does not topple.

      Marking points

      • Turns it back onto its base (it does not topple)
    4. (d)Suggest two ways of making the cabinet more stable.

      2 marks
      Show the answer

      Answer: Keep the heaviest files in the bottom drawers to lower its centre of gravity, and give it a wider base.

      Marking points

      • Lower the centre of gravity (heavy files in the bottom drawers)
      • Widen the base
  4. 4.Ideas about stability are used in designing vehicles and toys.

    1. (a)Explain why racing cars are built low, with their wheels set wide apart.

      2 marks
      Show the answer

      Answer: Building the car low gives it a low centre of gravity, and wide-set wheels give it a wide base. Both mean it must tilt a long way before it overturns on a sharp bend.

      Marking points

      • Low body gives a low centre of gravity
      • Wheels set wide apart give a wide base (harder to overturn)
    2. (b)Explain how a balancing toy returns to its position after it is tipped.

      2 marks
      Show the answer

      Answer: Its heavy parts hang below the pivot, so its centre of gravity is below the point of support. Tipping raises the centre of gravity, and the weight's torque brings it back down to its lowest position.

      Marking points

      • Centre of gravity is below the pivot
      • Tipping raises G; the weight's torque returns it to its lowest (stable) position
    3. (c)Explain why a passenger van with heavy luggage on its roof is more likely to overturn on a sharp bend.

      2 marks
      Show the answer

      Answer: The luggage raises the van's centre of gravity. A smaller tilt is then enough for the vertical line through it to pass outside the base, so the van overturns more easily.

      Marking points

      • Luggage on the roof raises the centre of gravity
      • A smaller tilt takes the line of action of the weight outside the base

Quick check

6 questions

  1. 1.A body that comes back to its original position after a slight tilt is in:
  2. 2.A cone lying on its curved side on a level table is in:
  3. 3.When a body in unstable equilibrium is tilted slightly, its centre of gravity:
  4. 4.Which change makes a bookshelf most stable?
  5. 5.A balancing toy keeps returning upright because its centre of gravity is:
  6. 6.A box tilted onto one edge will topple when: