Core: nuclear emission is spontaneous and random; alpha is a helium nucleus, beta a fast electron from the nucleus and gamma electromagnetic radiation; alpha ionises most and penetrates least, gamma the reverse. Supplement: deflection in electric and magnetic fields, and why alpha ionises most.
A smoke alarm in Nairobi holds a speck of americium that gives out alpha particles, while plants in Mumbai sterilise syringes with gamma rays. This page (syllabus 5.2.2) shows how to tell the three nuclear emissions apart. Detectors and background radiation are in 5.2.1.
Spontaneous and random (Core)
Nothing triggers a nucleus to decay: heating it, squeezing it or combining it chemically makes no difference. Nobody can say which nucleus will emit next, or in which direction its emission will fly out. So a detector beside a source gives a slightly different count every minute.
Identifying the three emissions (Core)
Alpha (α)
Beta (β)
Gamma (γ)
Nature
Helium nucleus: 2 protons and 2 neutrons
Fast-moving electron, emitted from the nucleus
Electromagnetic radiation from the nucleus
Relative charge
+2
−1
0
Ionising effect
Strongest
Weaker than alpha
Weakest
Penetrating ability
Lowest: a sheet of paper absorbs it
Medium: a few millimetres of aluminium absorbs it
Highest: thick lead or concrete only reduces it
Ionising and penetrating are linked. Each ionisation costs the emission energy, so the stronger the ioniser, the sooner it runs out and the less it gets through.
Why alpha ionises most (Supplement)
To ionise an atom, an emission must tear an electron out of it.
Alpha has the largest charge, +2, so it pulls hard on every electron it passes. It also carries plenty of kinetic energy to spend on ionising.
Beta has half that size of charge and usually less kinetic energy. It moves much faster, so it spends less time near each atom and ionises far fewer of them.
Gamma has no charge at all. It ionises only on the rare occasions it interacts with an electron.
Deflection in fields (Supplement)
Field
Alpha
Beta
Gamma
Electric (between charged plates)
Slightly, towards the negative plate
Strongly, towards the positive plate
Not deflected
Magnetic (across the beam)
Slightly, one way
Strongly, the opposite way
Not deflected
Opposite charges explain the opposite directions. Beta bends far more, and the reason to give in an exam is its mass: a beta particle has only a tiny fraction of an alpha particle's mass. That is a simplification, because the size of a bend also depends on the particle's charge and speed. For typical energies, beta bends only a few times more than alpha between charged plates, but tens of times more in a magnetic field. In a magnetic field, find the direction with Fleming's left-hand rule: the current points the way alpha moves, but opposite to the way beta moves.
Worked example: identifying beams (Supplement)
A beam with all three emissions travels left to right between two horizontal plates. The top plate is positive and the bottom one negative. Three spots appear on a screen: X far above the centre, Y at the centre and Z a little below it.
Y is undeflected, so it is uncharged: gamma.
Z is pulled slightly towards the negative plate, so it is positive: alpha. Its large mass keeps the bend small.
X is pulled strongly towards the positive plate, so it is negative: beta.
If the plates are swapped, alpha and beta change sides while gamma stays at the centre.
Testing the emissions yourself
In the simulation above, the GM tube starts 3 cm in front of the Alpha source in Penetration. There is no absorber, the background is set to 20 counts/min and each count lasts 1 minute. After each change, press Skip to finish the new count at once.
(Core) Press Skip: the count rate is about 1000 counts/min. Choose Paper under Absorber. The rate falls to about 20 counts/min, the background on its own.
(Core) Choose Beta under Source. Behind paper it still gives about 720 counts/min; with Aluminium (3 mm) it drops to about 20.
(Core) Choose Gamma. Aluminium hardly changes it; Lead (2 cm) lowers it to about 400 counts/min, still well above background.
(Core) Press Ionising under the stage. The cards give about 40 000, 100 and 1 ion pairs per cm of air (these numbers are beyond the syllabus).
(Supplement) Press Fields. With Top +, alpha bends down towards the − plate and beta up towards the + plate; press Flip to swap them. Under Field, choose Magnetic. Alpha's bend is drawn 20 times larger at first; switch off Draw alpha's bend larger to see its true size.
Common mistakes
✕Treating beta particles as orbiting electrons knocked off the atom. A beta particle is an electron that comes out of the nucleus itself.
✕Describing gamma as a particle with a charge or a mass. Gamma is electromagnetic radiation: it has no charge and no mass.
✕Mixing up ionising and penetrating. Alpha is the most strongly ionising but the least penetrating; gamma is the least ionising but the most penetrating.
✕Believing a lead block can absorb every gamma ray. Even very thick lead or concrete only cuts the amount down; a little always passes.
✕Thinking that heating a source, or changing its chemical form, makes its nuclei emit sooner. Emission is spontaneous, and which nucleus emits next, and in which direction, is random.
✕(Supplement) Claiming that alpha particles are deflected more than beta particles because their charge is bigger. Beta particles are deflected far more, because their mass is so much smaller, and the two bend in opposite directions.
Exam-style questions
Original questions written in the style of Cambridge IGCSE. Try each one before you reveal the answer.
1.Unstable nuclei can emit alpha particles, beta particles and gamma rays.
(a)State what an alpha particle consists of.
2 marks
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: Two protons and two neutrons bound together: a helium nucleus.
Marking points
two protons
two neutrons (accept: a helium nucleus, for both marks)
(b)Describe the nature of a beta particle.
2 marks
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: It is a fast-moving electron that is emitted from the nucleus.
Marking points
an electron (fast-moving)
emitted from the nucleus
(c)State what type of radiation gamma is.
1 mark
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: Electromagnetic radiation.
Marking points
electromagnetic radiation (wave)
(d)State which of the three emissions is the most strongly ionising.
1 mark
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: Alpha.
Marking points
alpha
2.A student points a radioactive source at a detector, which feeds a counter, then puts different absorbers between them. The background count is so small that it can be ignored. The count rates are: no absorber, 480 counts/min; one sheet of paper, 476 counts/min; 5 mm of aluminium, 0 counts/min.
(a)Identify the type of emission given out by the source.
1 mark
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: Beta.
Marking points
beta
(b)Explain how the readings show this.
3 marks
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: Paper makes almost no difference, so there is no alpha. The aluminium absorbs everything, which is what beta does. Nothing gets through the aluminium, so there is no gamma.
Marking points
paper causes almost no drop, so no alpha
5 mm of aluminium absorbs it all, as it does beta
nothing passes the aluminium, so no gamma
(c)The reading with no absorber is repeated and gives 491 counts/min. Suggest why the two readings differ.
1 mark
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: Radioactive emission is random, so the number of emissions in a minute varies.
Marking points
emission (decay) is random
3.Physicists describe nuclear emission as both spontaneous and random.
(a)Explain what is meant by spontaneous.
1 mark
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: It happens without any outside cause; conditions such as temperature or pressure have no effect on it.
Marking points
not triggered or affected by external conditions (e.g. temperature, pressure)
(b)Explain what is meant by random.
1 mark
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: No one can tell in advance which nucleus will emit next, when it will do so, or in which direction the emission will travel.
Marking points
cannot predict which nucleus emits, when, or in which direction
(c)State the order of alpha, beta and gamma by penetrating ability, starting with the least penetrating.
1 mark
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: Alpha, beta, gamma.
Marking points
alpha, beta, gamma
(d)Suggest an absorber that stops almost all beta particles but lets most gamma rays through.
1 mark
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: A sheet of aluminium a few millimetres thick.
Marking points
aluminium, a few mm thick
4.In a vacuum, a narrow horizontal beam containing alpha particles, beta particles and gamma rays passes between two parallel horizontal metal plates. The upper plate is negative and the lower plate is positive.
(a)(Supplement) Describe the path of each of the three emissions between the plates.
3 marks
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: Alpha particles curve slightly upwards, towards the negative plate. Beta particles curve strongly downwards, towards the positive plate. Gamma rays carry straight on.
Marking points
alpha: bends slightly towards the upper (negative) plate
beta: bends strongly towards the lower (positive) plate
gamma: undeflected
(b)(Supplement) Explain why beta particles are deflected much more than alpha particles.
2 marks
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: A beta particle has a far smaller mass than an alpha particle. So even though its charge, and so the force on it, is only half as big, its sideways acceleration is far greater.
Marking points
beta particle has a much smaller mass
so it has a much greater (sideways) acceleration, even though its charge (the force on it) is smaller
(c)(Supplement) The plates are removed and a magnetic field is applied at right angles to the beam. Compare the directions in which alpha and beta particles are deflected.
1 mark
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: They are deflected in opposite directions.
Marking points
opposite directions
(d)(Supplement) Explain, with reference to charge and kinetic energy, why alpha particles are more strongly ionising than beta particles.
2 marks
Show the answerHide the answer
Answer: Alpha particles have a larger charge (+2), so they exert larger forces on the electrons of the atoms they pass. They also have a large kinetic energy and move slowly, so they ionise very many atoms along a short path.
Marking points
larger charge (+2), so stronger forces on electrons in atoms
large kinetic energy and slow speed, so very many ionisations close together