Skip to content

Rutherford's Gold Foil Experiment: What It Showed and Why It Changed the Atom

A student guide to the alpha scattering experiment: who did it, what the plum pudding model predicted, the three key observations and what each one proves, why gold and alpha particles were chosen, and how Bohr and Chadwick built on the nuclear model.

Published · 8 min read

On this page

In the gold foil experiment, a thin beam of alpha particles was aimed at a sheet of gold far thinner than paper, and the scientists recorded where each one ended up. Nearly all of them passed straight through. A small number swerved, and a tiny few came back towards the source. Those rare rebounds proved that an atom is not a soft, even ball of charge. Its positive charge and almost all of its mass sit in a tiny nucleus at the centre, and the rest of the atom is mostly empty space.

Hans Geiger and Ernest Marsden first saw alpha particles bounce back in 1909, in Ernest Rutherford's laboratory in Manchester. Rutherford explained the results in 1911, and the pair's more careful measurements, published in 1913, matched his explanation. His nuclear model replaced J. J. Thomson's plum pudding model, and every later picture of the atom has been built on it.

What did scientists expect to happen?

In 1897 Thomson discovered the electron. It is negative, and it has only a tiny fraction of the mass of even the lightest atom. Atoms are neutral overall, so something positive must balance the electrons. In 1904 Thomson suggested that the positive charge fills the whole atom evenly, with the electrons scattered through it like currants in a pudding.

In that model, nothing inside an atom can push hard on a fast alpha particle. The positive charge is spread so thinly that its push is weak. Each electron is thousands of times lighter than an alpha particle, like a table-tennis ball in the path of a cricket ball. So the prediction was that every alpha particle would cross the foil, turning by only a degree or so.

How was the experiment set up?

  • A radioactive source sat inside a block of lead. A narrow hole let the alpha particles out as a thin beam.
  • The beam struck a gold foil about 0.0004 mm thick.
  • A small screen coated with zinc sulfide gave a tiny flash of light wherever an alpha particle landed. Sitting in a darkened room, the scientists counted the flashes through a microscope, one by one.
  • The screen and microscope could be moved to view the foil from different angles.
  • The air was pumped out, because a few centimetres of air stops alpha particles.

What were the three results, and what does each one show?

What they sawHow commonWhat it tells us
Alpha particles passed through with little or no change of directionNearly every oneMost of the volume of an atom is empty space
Alpha particles swerved through large anglesA small fractionThe positive charge is crowded into a small region, which repels the positive alpha particles strongly
Alpha particles came back, turned through more than 90°Very rareThat small region also holds nearly all of the atom's mass

Passing straight through. Each alpha particle crossed roughly 1500 layers of gold atoms. If most kept going in a straight line, they met nothing solid or strongly charged on the way. So most of each atom must be empty. Electrons do occupy that space, but they are far too light to turn an alpha particle.

Large swerves. Positive charge repels a positive alpha particle. A strong push needs a lot of charge packed close together, with the alpha particle passing near it. Only a few swerved sharply, so only a few came that close: the positive centre must be tiny.

Coming back. To turn round a fast, heavy object, you need something heavier than it. A table-tennis ball cannot send a cricket ball back towards the bowler, but a wall can. A gold nucleus has about 49 times the mass of an alpha particle. When an alpha particle heads almost straight at one, the repulsion slows it, stops it and drives it back the way it came. The two never actually touch.

Why gold foil, and why alpha particles?

Gold can be beaten into extraordinarily thin sheets without tearing. In a thin foil, each alpha particle passes relatively few atoms, so a big swerve most likely comes from one close meeting with one nucleus. Each gold nucleus is also heavy and strongly charged, so the effects are easy to see.

Alpha particles were the best tool available. They are fast and positive, and each one outweighs an electron by a factor of about 7300. A radioactive source supplies them steadily, and each one makes a visible flash on zinc sulfide.

How small is the nucleus?

Atoms have a radius of about 1×10−101 \times 10^{-10} m. A nucleus is more than 10 000 times narrower than its atom.

Worked example 1: an atom the size of a cricket ground

A large cricket ground in Lahore is about 150 m across. Imagine an atom enlarged to that size. If the nucleus is at most 1/10 000 of the width of the atom, how wide is it?

Equation: width of nucleus = width of atom ÷ 10 000

Substitution: 150÷10 000=0.015150 \div 10\,000 = 0.015 m

Answer: at most 0.015 m, or 1.5 cm: a marble on the pitch, holding almost all the mass of the stadium-sized atom. For gold, the ratio is closer to 1 to 20 000, so the marble would shrink to about 7.5 mm.

Worked example 2: how rare were the rebounds?

In 1909, Geiger and Marsden estimated that about 1 alpha particle in 8000 came back from a thick platinum plate. Suppose 400 000 alpha particles hit such a plate. How many would you expect to come back, and what percentage is that?

Number back: 400 000÷8000=50400\,000 \div 8000 = 50

Percentage: 50400 000×100=0.0125%\dfrac{50}{400\,000} \times 100 = 0.0125\%

Answer: about 50 alpha particles, roughly one hundredth of one per cent. Thin gold foil sends back an even smaller share.

How is the nuclear model different from plum pudding?

  • Positive charge: Thomson spread it evenly through the whole atom. Rutherford packed all of it into the nucleus.
  • Mass: in the pudding, mass is shared out across the atom. In the nuclear model, the nucleus has nearly all of it.
  • Electrons: Thomson placed them inside the positive charge. Rutherford placed them outside the nucleus, far from it.
  • Empty space: the pudding has none. The nuclear atom is mostly empty.

The plum pudding model was not a careless guess: it fitted the evidence of 1904. New results that it could not explain forced a change, which is how science should work.

What did Bohr and Chadwick add later?

  • Niels Bohr, 1913. In Bohr's model, each electron can circle the nucleus only at one of a set of allowed distances, now called energy levels or shells. Calculations from the model matched the colours of light that hot hydrogen gives out.
  • The proton, around 1920. Experiments showed that every nucleus carries a whole number of units of positive charge, each unit being the charge of a hydrogen nucleus. Rutherford named this particle the proton.
  • James Chadwick, 1932. Nuclei had more mass than their protons alone could explain. Chadwick's experiments showed that nuclei also contain neutrons, which have no charge and about the same mass as a proton. That was 21 years after Rutherford's nuclear model.

Neutrons explain isotopes: see our guide to isotopes and nuclide notation.

You can run the experiment yourself in our Rutherford scattering simulation. Press Fire to send a burst of alpha particles at the gold foil, and watch the Bounced back card. Then switch to Plum pudding and fire again: the Largest angle card stays at a degree or two, and nothing comes back. A timeline under the stage traces the model from Dalton to Chadwick.

Common mistakes

  • Saying the alpha particles hit the nucleus and bounced off it. They are repelled before they reach it.
  • Blaming the electrons for the large swerves. Electrons are far too light to turn an alpha particle sharply.
  • Saying the experiment showed electron shells. Shells came from Bohr's work, two years after Rutherford's explanation.
  • Saying the experiment discovered protons or neutrons. It revealed the nucleus. Protons were named later, and neutrons were found in 1932.
  • Giving only the observation. Exam answers need the conclusion too: "most passed straight through, so the atom is mostly empty space".

Key points

  • Alpha particles were fired at very thin gold foil in a vacuum, and counted at different angles.
  • Most passed straight through, so the atom is mostly empty space.
  • A few swerved sharply, so the positive charge is concentrated in a tiny region.
  • A very few came back, so that tiny region, the nucleus, holds almost all of the mass.
  • The nuclear model took over from the plum pudding model because it explained results the older model could not.
  • Bohr added fixed electron distances in 1913, and Chadwick showed in 1932 that neutrons exist.