Spec point 4.4.1.3: who needs it
All AQA students learn this, on either tier, in GCSE Physics and Combined Science alike; GCSE Chemistry shares it. There is no equation. Aim to:
- compare the plum pudding and nuclear models
- explain why the scattering results ended the plum pudding model
- state what Niels Bohr and James Chadwick added (not their experiments)
- explain why fresh evidence can force a model to change
The specification names only Bohr and Chadwick; other names and all dates here are background. Atom and nucleus sizes are in 4.4.1.1.
Before the nucleus
Through most of the 1800s, the atom was the smallest known piece of matter, pictured as a solid ball. In 1897 J. J. Thomson found the electron, a negative particle far lighter than any atom, so atoms had parts after all.
Atoms are neutral, so Thomson's plum pudding model (1904) spreads positive charge through the whole atom like dough, with the negative electrons dotted through it like fruit. Charge and mass are both spread out, and there is no nucleus.
Testing the model
In 1909, in Ernest Rutherford's Manchester laboratory, Hans Geiger and Ernest Marsden fired alpha particles at very thin gold foil inside a vacuum. An alpha particle is a helium nucleus: fast, positive and about 7300 times heavier than an electron. The plum pudding model predicted that every one would cross the foil almost undisturbed, as thinly spread charge pushes only gently.
Worked explanation: what each result shows
Rutherford explained the results in 1911. Take each observation in turn.
- Most alpha particles went straight through. Nothing in their path pushed them, so most of an atom is empty space.
- A few swerved through large angles. That takes a strong push. Positive charge repels a positive alpha particle, so the atom's positive charge must be squeezed into a small region.
- A very few bounced back. Reversing a fast alpha particle needs an object much heavier than it. So nearly all of the atom's mass is packed into that same tiny region: the nucleus.
The plum pudding model could not explain results 2 and 3, so the nuclear model replaced it.
| Feature | Plum pudding model | Nuclear model |
|---|---|---|
| Positive charge | spread through the whole atom | concentrated in a tiny central nucleus |
| Mass | spread through the whole atom | almost all in the nucleus |
| Electrons | dotted through the positive charge | outside the nucleus |
| Empty space | none | most of the atom |
Worked example: reading the counts
Made-up counts matching the simulation's model: of 52 000 detected, 51 740 turn by less than 10° and 2 by more than 90°.
- Nearly undeflected: 51 740 ÷ 52 000 × 100 = 99.5%.
- Sent back: 52 000 ÷ 2 = 26 000, so about 1 in 26 000.
Beyond the specification: real shares vary with the foil and the energy. The famous 1909 figure of about 1 in 8000 coming back was for a thick platinum plate, not gold foil.
After Rutherford
- Niels Bohr (1913): electrons orbit the nucleus only at certain fixed distances, called energy levels or shells. Bohr's calculations matched experiments, so the idea was accepted.
- Protons (named around 1920): further experiments showed that every nucleus carries its charge on identical positive particles, so the charge always counts up in whole steps.
- James Chadwick (1932): evidence for neutrons, uncharged particles in the nucleus with about the same mass as a proton, some twenty years after the nucleus was proposed.
Each change came from evidence the old model could not fit: the plum pudding model was sensible in 1904, but not after the scattering results. In an answer, name the result it failed to explain.
In the simulation above
It starts on the Nuclear model, with Alpha particle energy at 5 MeV.
- Press Fire under the stage: 20 000 alpha particles leave the lead box, and the beam keeps running. When the flashes land, Through, under 10° reads close to 99.5%.
- Press Fire four more times and watch Bounced back: at about 1 in 26 000, expect only a few.
- Switch to Plum pudding, then Fire once more. Nothing returns, and Largest angle stays near 1°. Compare the rows of Both models so far.
- In How the model of the atom changed, each step has an AQA tag; Bohr's and Chadwick's say "no experiment details".
The counts, the energy slider and Show the formula’s prediction go beyond GCSE.